4134 Garrett Road, Ithaca, NY 14850 US Ithaca Home

4134 Garrett Road, Ithaca , New York

Your Heart's Desire.

Property Details



Listing Information

  • Bedrooms: 4
  • Baths: 2
  • Partial Baths: 0
  • SQ FT: 2421
  • Lot Size: 40.285 Acres
  • Style: Greek Revival
  • Garage: 2 Car Barn
  • Heat Source: Fuel oil
  • Schools: Ithaca City School District

Property Description

This idyllic 4 BR, 2 Bath Romantic Greek Revival has refinished wide plank floors, beautiful original molding and spacious rooms. A huge farmhouse kitchen with rustic barnwood cabinets and all new appliances. It sits on 40 Acres. Enjoy sweeping views from your front porch. Three pre-Civil War barns dot the landscape and one of them has an artist studio inside! 

There’s a spring-fed pond, meadows and an heirloom apple orchard. Wait until you see the berry patch! Tasty berries galore – delicious both fresh or when cooked into jams and pies. Red and green gooseberries; white, red and black currants. 

ALL NEW plumbing and electric. NEW Jotul Woodstove. Buderus boiler. Whole house attic fan. Main floor laundry/mudroom. Workshop. Borders the Black Diamond Trail. There’s even a winter lake view! Oh, and a wine cellar too.  Just 5 miles to Taughannock and 6 miles to downtown. Ithaca Schools. Your Heart’s Desire. HERE you can create the life you really want.

NOTE: Current owners are only the 3rd owners since the original Garrett Sisters! Was once a sheep farm. The land has never been treated with pesticides -- organic practices only.


Please wait...

Request More Information

  • 4134 Garrett Road
  • Required
  • Required

Equal Housing Opportunity

Property information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be verified.


Contact Information

Photo of Laurel Guy NYS Associate Broker  Real Estate
Laurel Guy NYS Associate Broker
Warren Real Estate of Ithaca
140 Seneca Way
Ithaca NY 14850
Fax: 607-277-2669