521 South Cayuga Street, Ithaca, NY 14850 US Ithaca Home

521 South Cayuga Street, Ithaca, New York

The Perfect Downtown Craftsman.

Property Details



Listing Information

  • MLS: 133581
  • Bedrooms: 5
  • Baths: 4
  • Partial Baths: 0
  • SQ FT: 2732
  • Lot Size: 38 x 45
  • Style: Craftsman
  • Heat Source: Gas
  • Schools: South Hill School

Property Description



A perfect Craftsman home on a perfectly quiet street in the heart of Ithaca. One of a kind. Perched in old South Hill, with a distant views. (Year-round glimpse of Cayuga Lake!) Walk everywhere. Car optional. Walk to the library, bus stop, the Commons, Gimme. You will live on the front porch and 3 season rear porch! Private courtyard with terraced perennial gardens.

This modern, warm house has been totally, meticulously renovated. Everything is new again, and the character and craftsmanship shines through. Every square inch of chestnut woodwork has been cleaned and refinished. Hardwood floors throughout. All new mechanicals, new roof, new kitchen.

Light. Light. Light. Watch the Ithaca sunset every day through the huge living room windows. (All windows are fully functional. Every sash scraped, sanded, refinished.) Open, spacious rooms. There are four levels of living space, with updated full baths on each level. The bathrooms are old school with new pieces blending in with the old. Two baths feature claw-foot tubs, two have showers. (His and Her baths!!)

Tons of storage. Huge, deep closets everywhere. The basement is dry and partially finished, with a sewing room, full bath, gym, workshop, and more storage. Exceptionally quiet neighborhood with very little traffic. Limited access street with NO odd and even parking rules. Ample parking.

DRIVING DIRECTIONS: Go on Turner Place, turn right on South Hill Terrace. Last house. At corner of South Hill Terrace and S. Cayuga St.

Please wait...

Request More Information

  • 521 South Cayuga Street
  • Required
  • Required

Equal Housing Opportunity

Property information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be verified.


Contact Information

Photo of Laurel Guy NYS Associate Broker  Real Estate
Laurel Guy NYS Associate Broker
Warren Real Estate of Ithaca
140 Seneca Way
Ithaca NY 14850
Fax: 607-277-2669